Learn how to make oatmeal and honey goat milk soap without lye, using this super simple soap recipe. Perfect for beginning soap makers as well as experienced melt and pour soapers.
There’s nothing quite as soothing as an oatmeal and honey goat milk soap, especially one you’ve made yourself. But if you’re a new soap maker, the entire process probably seems daunting. Particularly working with lye.
That’s why this oatmeal and honey goat milk soap recipe is perfect for beginners. It’s made without lye (at least, the lye step has already been done for you so you don’t have to do it.)

It uses the melt and pour soap method with a premade goat’s milk soap base, so it’s super easy to make and ready to use as soon as you pop it from the mold. The melt and pour method is the method I started with when I first began making soap all those years ago, and I highly recommend new soapers start off this way too.
Another plus — this bar is gentle enough for face and body. And great for kids too!
This is the very same soap recipe I used years and years ago for my older two children, now 20 and 23, when they were babies. (By the time my youngest child came along I had gotten over my fear of lye and was making cold process soap.)
If you’re completely new to melt and pour soap, you’ll want to check out this post: A Beginner’s Guide to Making Soap Without Lye. It will answer all of your soaping questions, from the supplies you need, how to choose the best soap bases. It’s all the questions I had when I first started making soap!
Melt and Pour Soap Making Tutorial
If you’ve never made melt and pour soap before, I’ve got a nifty tutorial for you here: How to Make Melt and Pour Soap.
You can also grab the Quick-Start Guide to Making Soap Without Lye. This is a free guide that I’ve created especially for beginning soap makers, to get you quickly and confidently crafting your own melt and pour soap.
In it you’ll find step-by-step soap making instructions plus a handy cheat sheet that tells you how much fragrance, color, herbs, essential oils (and more) to add to your soap. With this guide you can start making your own custom soap bars right away.
I’d love to send it to you, so just enter your info below.

A step-by-step guide to making your own homemade soap without lye. Plus you’ll get a fragrance and additives chart, so you can start making your own beautiful, custom creations fast.
Enter your name and email below, and I’ll send you the guide right away.
By signing up, you’ll also be subscribed to my newsletter for more DIY skin care recipes and mini courses. Don’t worry; no spam ever and unsubscribe any time. View my privacy policy.
Pin to save this recipe!
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This means I may receive a small commission—at no extra cost to you—from any sales made through these links. I only recommend products that I personally use and love! View my affiliate disclosure.
RECIPE: Oatmeal and Honey Goat Milk Soap – Melt and Pour Method
Ready to get soaping! This recipe makes a beautiful bar of oatmeal and honey goat milk soap, and it is so easy. You can get everything you need for this one at your local craft store.
If you don’t have, or don’t care for, goat milk soap base, please feel free to substitute with whatever melt and pour soap base you have on hand.
This recipe makes 1 lb. or 4 (4 oz.) bars of soap.
Ingredients:
- 1 lb. goat’s milk soap base (most soap base comes in 2 lbs. blocks, check the weight on your package; cut in half and save the rest for another project!)
- 2 tablespoons oats, ground into a fine powder (here’s how)
- 1 tablespoon honey
You’ll also need:
- Small pot or double boiler
- Silicone spatula or spoon for stirring
- Ladle or large spoon
- Silicone soap mold or silicone muffin cups (I used these sweet little heart-shaped cups for this project and they were adorable)
- Small spritz bottle (like these) filled with rubbing alcohol
Step 1: Cut the goat’s milk soap base into approximately 1 inch chunks. No need to be neat about it, just cut it up and toss the pieces into a small pot.
Step 2: On low heat, warm the soap base gently until just melted. Don’t allow the soap to come to a simmer otherwise it may scorch.
Step 3: While you’re waiting for the soap to melt, place the oatmeal and honey into a small bowl and stir until well mixed. You’ll end up with a rather stiff mixture, but if you’re having trouble getting the oats completely incorporated you can add a bit more honey.
Premixing these ingredients makes it way easier to blend into your soap. Otherwise, that oatmeal powder tends to clump and you’ll have oatmeal chunks in your soap. Not pretty.
Step 4: Once the soap base is completely melted, add the oat and honey mixture into the melted base and stir. Mix well until completely blended throughout the soap.
I like to keep the soap base on the heat while I do this, because oats have a tendency to tighten the soap base. Keeping it on the heat counteracts this.
Step 5:
Remove from heat and, using a ladle or large spoon, pour soap base into each cavity of the soap mold. (If the soap base thickens too much to work with, just place it back on the heat for a minute or so to remelt. Easy peasy lemon squeezy!)
Step 6: Once the soap base is in the mold, immediately spritz the surface of the soap with rubbing alcohol. This will pop any bubbles that have formed.
Step 7: Let the soap set undisturbed for several hours or overnight to completely harden.
Tip: Don’t move or jostle your soap molds until the soap is completely solidified. Otherwise you’ll end up with “ripples” on the bars. It won’t hurt your soap but does affect how pretty it looks.
Step 8: Press your soap bars from the mold. Your soap is ready to use or give!
How to store your soap: Melt and pour soap bars should be kept tightly wrapped in plastic wrap or cellophane to protect them from moisture.
Shelf life: Your soap bars will last 2 years or more, as long as they are kept tightly wrapped and away from moisture.
Enjoy your oatmeal and honey goat milk soap, made without lye!
I’m very new to making soaps and I was wondering if I could swap the goat milk base for any other base?
Will this affect the soap in anyway
Looking forward to trying this out! 😊
Hi Elise! What a great question!
Yes, you can swap out the goat's milk base for ANY other base you'd like. All melt and pour soap bases are used in exactly the same way, so you can safely substitute melt and pour soap bases in a recipe. All other ingredients and the process itself stays the same.
I hope this helps you out! Thanks for the comment.
<3 Angela
Hello ,
Can I add essential oils to those honey and oats ?
Hi Selina,
Yes, you can add essential oils or fragrance oils to this recipe. I’d recommend using 0.25 to 0.5 ounces of essential oil to this size batch. Stir in with the honey and oats.
Thanks for your comment! I hope you like your soap. 🙂
Angela
I want to sub this with Castile soap. Does Castile soap dry you out more though?
You can definitely substitute any melt and pour soap base for this recipe. Castile would make a nice oat and honey soap!
Some Castile soap bases can be drying, while others aren’t. It also depends on your skin type. Some skin loves Castile, while others find it too cleansing. So, the unhelpful answer is, it depends! I’d make up a small batch and see how you like it. 🙂
You need to retitle your post. All soap has lye in it. Saying in your title that you are making it without lye is just misleading. Even if you note further down, as an afternote, that the saponification process has already happened in the melt and pour variety, your title is misinforming.
Thanks for your comment. I understand where you’re coming from, however, with melt and pour soap you are making soap without handling lye. That’s not to say that the soap doesn’t have lye in it, it certainly does! But you’re not using it yourself.
You sound like an experienced soap maker. Brand-spankin’-new soap makers, those who are just looking into the process of HOW to make soap, are often intimidated about the process of using lye. So, they search for ways to “make soap without lye.” My title was chosen to help those new soap makers find their way here, where they can then learn the ins-and-outs of soap making, including making soap using the melt and pour method without handling lye at all.
So, with respect, I don’t think my title is misleading. You are making soap without lye: you’re not buying lye, nor handling it yourself. But I do appreciate your taking the time to comment. 🙂